Do Tennessee Businesses Need Earthquake Insurance? Earth Movement Exclusions and Percentage Deductibles
In May 2025, a magnitude 4.1 earthquake centered about 12 miles from Greenback, roughly 30 miles south of Knoxville, generated more than 23,000 public shaking reports to the U.S. Geological Survey in its first hour. Nobody was hurt and there was no major damage. But it raised a question that rarely comes up at an East Tennessee renewal: if a stronger one hit, would the commercial property policy pay?
For most programs, the honest answer is no — not unless earthquake was deliberately added.
Why the standard policy excludes earthquake
The ISO and AAIS causes-of-loss forms used on most commercial property policies exclude earthquake damage through an earth movement exclusion that applies regardless of any other cause contributing concurrently or in sequence. There is one important exception: if earth movement results in fire or explosion, the fire or explosion damage is covered. Shaking that cracks a foundation, drops pallet racking or collapses a masonry wall is not.
Earthquake is added by endorsement, typically ISO CP 10 40 at full policy limits with a coinsurance clause, or CP 10 45 as a sublimit without coinsurance, or through a carrier’s own form or a separate policy.
How real is the risk in Tennessee?
Tennessee sits between two seismic sources: the New Madrid Seismic Zone to the west and the East Tennessee Seismic Zone, where the 2025 quake occurred. Reporting on that event, Insurance Journal noted that 15 other magnitude 4-plus earthquakes have struck within about 155 miles since 1950, the largest a magnitude 4.7 near Knoxville in November 1973, and a USGS spokeswoman explained that eastern earthquakes are felt over much larger distances than western ones because of the region’s geology. Small events keep coming: in one week of July 2026, USGS recorded four quakes in four days near Mascot, Tellico Village, Greenback and Rutledge.
The science is still developing. A 2026 assessment of the East Tennessee zone by University of Memphis seismologists Christine Powell and Charles Langston relocated 1,657 earthquakes recorded between 1984 and 2021 and identified bands of activity that may mark more coherent fault planes. Nationally, the USGS 2023 National Seismic Hazard Model, released in January 2024, found that nearly 75 percent of the United States could experience damaging shaking over the next century.
None of that makes a damaging East Tennessee earthquake likely in a given year. It makes it a low-frequency, high-severity exposure — one that deserves a decision rather than a default.
How earthquake deductibles change the math
Earthquake coverage rarely carries the flat deductible on the rest of the schedule. It is usually a percentage of insured value, and guidance published by ICMA notes those deductibles can range from 2 percent to 20 percent of the property’s value, applied separately to each building and to the contents in it.
For example (illustrative only): a Knoxville distributor insures a $6 million warehouse and $3 million of stock and equipment with a 5 percent earthquake deductible. A moderate quake causes $400,000 of structural damage and $150,000 of racking collapse and damaged inventory. The building deductible is $300,000 and the contents deductible is $150,000, so the policy pays $100,000 on a $550,000 loss. At a 2 percent deductible, the same loss pays $370,000.
Coverage details worth checking
- Business income. Time-element coverage responds only to a covered physical loss, so earthquake has to extend to business income and extra expense, not just the building. Our briefing on how much business income insurance you need covers sizing.
- Ordinance or law. Code-upgrade costs after a quake are excluded unless ordinance or law coverage is added.
- Full limits or a sublimit. A sublimit keeps premium down but caps recovery; a full-limit form brings coinsurance with it, which makes current values essential — see our note on insurance-to-value and coinsurance penalties.
- Occurrence definition. Earthquake coverage commonly treats all quakes within a 168-hour period as one occurrence, which matters for aftershocks and for how many deductibles apply.
- Water from broken lines. Confirm how your forms treat sprinkler and plumbing damage caused by shaking.
Questions to ask your broker before renewal
- Does our property program include earthquake today, and at which locations?
- How is our earthquake deductible calculated — per building, per contents, or per location?
- Does the earthquake coverage extend to business income, extra expense and ordinance or law?
- What would full-limit coverage cost on our most critical site, and what would a sublimit cost?
- Do any leases or loan agreements require earthquake coverage we do not carry?
At Peoples First Tennessee, earthquake is a choice we surface during Strategic Discovery rather than leave to the policy form. Risk Assessment weighs construction, occupancy and location; Solution Design prices full limits against sublimits and deductible options; and Ongoing Optimization revisits the choice as values change. For the broader picture, start with our guide to business insurance in Knoxville, TN.
Sources: Insurance Journal — Magnitude 4.1 earthquake strikes East Tennessee (May 12, 2025); Weatherboy — Fourth earthquake strikes Tennessee in four days, citing USGS (July 9, 2026); Powell & Langston — New assessment of the Eastern Tennessee seismic zone (University of Memphis CERI, 2026); USGS — New USGS map shows where damaging earthquakes are most likely to occur in US (Jan. 16, 2024); ICMA — Earthquake Insurance (PDF)
— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor