Active Assailant Coverage and the Gaps in Standard Commercial Liability Policies in 2026
There is a particular kind of risk that most business owners would rather not name, and most standard insurance policies are quietly built to avoid. An active assailant event — a shooting, a vehicle attack, a deliberate act of violence against the people inside your four walls — sits in a category all its own. It is not an accident. It is not negligence in the ordinary sense. And when the dust settles, the policy you assumed would respond often discovers reasons not to. That gap is not an oversight. It is architecture.
Consider how a Commercial General Liability policy is actually constructed. CGL was designed to answer for negligence — the wet floor, the falling signage, the accident nobody intended. Its coverage trigger turns on the word "occurrence," and an occurrence means an accident. A deliberate act of violence is the opposite of an accident, which means the foundational trigger of the policy is working against the claim before anyone reads a single exclusion. Then the exclusions arrive. Most CGL forms carry an assault-and-battery exclusion and, frequently, an abuse-or-molestation exclusion — provisions written precisely to carve intentional harm out of the grant of coverage. In February of this year, a Louisiana appellate panel held that a CGL policy's assault-and-battery exclusion unambiguously barred coverage for a wrongful-death claim arising from a fatal shooting. That ruling did not invent a new principle. It illuminated one that had been hiding in the form all along.
The shortfalls compound from there. A CGL policy responds to third-party bodily injury and property damage — it does not pay to counsel your surviving employees, it does not fund the public-relations effort that keeps your doors from closing, and it carries no crisis-management component whatsoever. Worse, the business-interruption question is almost cruelly circular. Interruption coverage under most property programs requires direct physical damage to property as its trigger. But an active assailant event can empty your building, collapse your revenue, and scatter your customers for months without breaking a single window. No physical damage, no business-interruption recovery — even as the losses mount by the day. And the natural instinct to reach for a terrorism policy fails too: the federal certification standard requires an ideological, political, or religious motive that most of these attacks never meet.
What a standalone active assailant policy does is invert that logic. Where the CGL asks whether anyone was negligent, the standalone policy asks whether people were harmed — and then it responds. These contracts are built to cover victim medical costs and counseling, often for years; death benefits and funeral expenses; business interruption and loss of attraction with no physical-damage requirement; crisis management and public relations; physical security upgrades such as panic systems and protective glass; and the legal liability that negligent-security litigation increasingly produces. Many pay benefits without waiting for a liability determination — they are designed to help a community recover, not merely to indemnify a balance sheet.
The market context makes the case more pointed than it was even two years ago. The FBI counted 24 active shooter incidents in 2024, down sharply from 48 the year before — but the longer arc tells the truer story: the 223 incidents recorded between 2020 and 2024 represent roughly a 70% increase over the prior five-year span. Carriers have read the same data. Casualty insurers have moved to limit or exclude active assailant exposures across retail, hospitality, entertainment, and real estate, which is exactly why the standalone market has moved from niche to mainstream. In a year when broad commercial property-casualty rates are actually softening, active assailant is one of the few perils still rising — Willis Towers Watson projects 2026 rate movement of roughly 2.5% to 10% upward, and the number of organizations buying the coverage has been climbing near 30% a year. Capacity has grown to meet the demand, with limits now reaching tens of millions for those who need them.
The discipline here is not the purchase — it is the diagnosis. A standalone policy bought without understanding what your other policies already exclude is a guess dressed up as a plan. This is where ownership of the risk belongs to you, and where a fiduciary approach earns its keep. At Peoples First, we work the problem through our 4-Step Strategic Process — Strategic Discovery to surface what matters most to your people and your operation, Risk Assessment to uncover where your current program goes silent, Solution Design to craft coverage that actually responds to a deliberate act, and Ongoing Optimization to keep that design aligned as the threat and the market both evolve.
The hard truth is that the policies most businesses already hold were never built to answer the question an active assailant event asks. The strategic response is not fear — it is clarity. Surface the gap before the event does, and you convert a hidden exposure into a controlled one.
Sources: Active assailant cover bucks the soft market; Active assailant coverage goes mainstream; Insurance marketplace realities 2026: Crisis management; FBI Releases New 2024 Active Shooter Incidents in the United States Report; Active assailant policies evolve amid continuing threats; Active Shooter Events: Coverage Options for Your Clients; Louisiana Panel: Assault And Battery Exclusion Bars Coverage For Shooting Death
— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor